Day one: Nana Upstairs, Nana Downstairs by Tomie De Paola. Great short story to get the small group going today. The skill I wanted to review was inferencing but somehow we shifted directions when one of them said "Who is talking? Who is telling this story?" and another one quickly answers "The author!" and points at Tomie's name. I sat for a second. They all three stared at me with questioning eyes. I said, "The author wrote the story. Do you know who is telling it?" ...silence...
So, later that day I turned to my new best friend that I had been studying and looked for answers. Long story short...if you are a reading teacher and have not yet discovered The Reading Strategies Book then you are missing out. For that matter, if you don't know Jennifer Serravallo then you are missing out. OK, back to my original thought...
Within the Reading Strategies Book (RSB) I found the first strategy I will set my students up with. It is found on page 175 and appropriately titled Who's Telling the Story? The language is easy to follow and the steps for implementation are quick and concise. Jennifer provides a list of prompts for students to use so they can become independent at this skill. I took those prompts and made a mini anchor chart so that they could each have their own.
To create ownership, my students each created their own mini chart of pronouns at the bottom of the prompts. This provided a visual of what they were looking for.
As we reread he text, the boys added to their chart by listing pronouns they found in their reading. When we were finished, they were able to see by their chart that the narrator was actually telling the story. For a first run...I call it a success!
How do you teach Independence to your readers that struggle?
What resources do you use, create or provide?



"... well planned lessons are not going to work with this group.." is such an important realization. It's one I've had often with the younger kiddos. It's why natural conversations are the best assessments! You find out what kids really need help with.
ReplyDelete